Rogue One (2016)
A Lot of Explosions for Two People Blending In
This week: Rogue One (2016). Rob watched it three different ways, Tom has notes on Andor, K-2SO remains the best character in Star Wars, and the last half hour forgives absolutely everything. Plus a fantasy Guess the Intro, the Ocarina of Time remake, and the politest queue in World of Warcraft hist
The verdict on Rogue One - A Star Wars Story
Tom4/5
Rob5/5
Rob liked it more, by 1 star.
Show notes
It's late at night, only one of us has got headphones, and it's all going a bit pear-shaped - but we're here, we're here, we're here. This week the Untitled Roulette lands on Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (2016): the scrolling text at the start of Episode 4 stretched into an entire film, the least Star Wars Star Wars film there is, and that might be exactly why it works.
First, Guess the Intro goes full fantasy. Six clips, zero sci-fi, and Tom reckons he's got six out of six. We've got the Great Conjunction, David Bowie in very tight trousers, Arnie not stealing everything he had (he didn't have time), the deep magic, exquisite gourmet rocks, and Bilbo's 111th birthday party. Don't message in. Don't waste your typing fingers. It will not be understood.
Then, what we've been up to. Rob's been living in All the Gear's camping videos, banking his way through Byker Grove, discovering Netflix has all the Red Dwarfs with impressively wrong episode descriptions, and playing the worst Game Boy game known to man: Star Trek Generations. Tom's been watching Miranda tear through the Ocarina of Time remake, explaining why he's not buying GTA 6 at launch, and queueing politely with thirty dwarves in World of Warcraft Forever - until someone skips the queue and the entire server turns.
And then, the main event. Rob watched Rogue One three different ways (Disney Plus on a browser is 720p, and you're a bunch of wankers for it), his notes are sporadic, and the film itself is a universe fucking trotter: too many planets, not enough story, a first act like pressing X to skip the cutscene and getting more cutscene. But then the last half hour arrives - a thirty-minute spunk fest of the best Star Wars fighting ever put on screen - and suddenly everything is forgiven.
Along the way: K-2SO is the best character in the film and it's not close (the slap was improvised, and you can see Diego Luna crack), Chirrut is the Jehovah's Witness of the Force ("Can I tell you about Luke Skywalker?"), CGI Leia should have stayed facing the other way (the croissants were enough), Andor is Tom's least favourite character and he's the one who got two series, and the Empire blows up its own archive - so how the fuck did they build the second Death Star? Stiddy, if you're listening, you're allowed to tell us. Nobody else is.
Plus: the wheel spins again, and Tom's first guess at the next film was The Pacifier, which tells you everything and nothing. He's thrilled. You're going to hear about Vin Diesel being typecast.
We swear a lot. You knew that already.
SPOILERS AHEAD - still, always. May the Force live long and prosper inside of you.
Social Details :
Find us on Twitter, Instagram, Threads, BlueSky and TikTok with @_UntitledSci-fi and @_Channel84.
Facebook, you can find us with Studio:Channel84.
We are part of the Studio:Channel84 network and are featured on their site https://channel84.co.uk.
Find all about our old episodes including all Guess the Intro answers and film scores over on https://untitledscifishow.co.uk/.
Finally, why not e-mail us:
Rob mailto://rob@channel84.co.uk
TJ mailto://tj@channel84.co.uk
Both Hosts mailto://podcasts@channel84.co.uk
Guess the Intro
Rob has cut 6 intros into one clip: films, shows, games, the odd talking computer. How many can you name?
- Unlocks 30 November
- Unlocks 30 November
- Unlocks 30 November
- Unlocks 30 November
- Unlocks 30 November
- Unlocks 30 November
Answers are revealed at the top of the next episode, and here on 30 November.
More episodes
The latest from the back catalogue.



